If you haven't seen the
movie and don't want to know what happens, then you may not want to
read this review, but if you've seen it already or probably won't,
then go ahead and read away...
This Summer fans of the
critically acclaimed HBO series, Sex and the City that has
now made its way into syndication with some edits, were thrilled to
find out what happened to the fantastic four -- Carrie (Sarah
Jessica Parker), Charlotte (Kristin Davis), Samantha (Kim Cattrall)
and Miranda (Cynthia Nixon). Die-hard fans were happy, but
for the less regular folks, like this reviewer, the movie, as a
movie, left something to be desired.
The male characters
especially were wooden, and there was virtually no sex in the movie
-- and not even much talk of sex, as the "girls" had to watch
their language around Charlotte's little girl. The only real
sex scene was awkward between Miranda and her husband, Steve (David
Eigenberg).
Samantha was relegated to
flying back and forth between the West Coast and the East Coast,
and she didn't have much in the way of action. She had lost
herself by agreeing to become a full time manager for her actor
lover, Smith (Jason Lewis). What made the demise of their
relationship really hard to watch is that he really loved her, but
she didn't love herself in that relationship, and in the end that's
all that counts. A brutal, but necessary truth to learn about
life and love.
Miranda had also lost
herself mostly in her relationship. When Steve had an affair
because she wasn't having sex with him regularly (the mostly
natural result of working all the time between "lawyering" and
"mommying"), she was initially unforgiving; she moved out of her
lovely Brownstone in Brooklyn (not an ideal choice for her, but it
did give her the space she needed, given that she was also caring
for a relative) into a slum in Chinatown, but she did ultimately
reconcile with Steve, which seemed more of a compromise than an
active choice -- if for no other reason than for the sake of her
financial purse and her son, or even perhaps so she wouldn't have
to be alone for another holiday.
Carrie finally gets the
proposal and begins planning all that she dreamed of in an enormous
wedding, but when that, like all previous efforts with Big (Chris
Noth) doesn't work out, she's devastated. About half the
movie, you feel her pain, as she can't even bare to have the light
coming in from the window.
The smart choice for Carrie
would have been to move on. Instead, she decides to marry
Big, despite the fact that he has shown nothing but cowardice when
it comes to his relationship with her. She gets married
before the Justice of the Peace, dressed in a far cry from the
designer gown she would have been married in had Big gone ahead
with the "Big Wedding."
It's disappointing to see
someone end up with such a flawed character as Big. No matter
what his wallet holds (and Carrie was certainly the one person in
the group that could not possibly have afforded her lifestyle on
her freelance writing, even with the advances on her books
given her shoe collection!), and no matter how big the closet he
was offering, she should have walked away.
The only person who really
wound up happy and fulfilled given her personality was
Charlotte. She ended up with Harry (Evan Handler), who
certainly wasn't much to look at, but what a mench! This man
really cared, and even after they adopted a little girl from China,
they ultimately were able to conceive a biological child of their
own to add to their already beautiful family. Charlotte's
choices were the only ones that made any sense in this less than
perfect movie.
What made the series so
great -- the snappy dialogue and the shots of New York City and its
hot spots -- was supplanted with overdone designer wedding dresses
and the need to bring Jennifer Hudson into the already crowded cast
as Carrie's assistant. What was she doing there?
Carrie's apartment wasn't really big enough to have an assistant
hanging out in there on the show and even with the redecorations
after she has to buy it back (after selling it because of the "Big
Wedding" fiasco).
All that being said, if you
are a true fan, you can't miss this movie. Seeing for
yourself what happens to these women, who all have something to
teach each one of us about relationships, makes this movie a Summer
must.
But caution if you're
considering it for a date movie. It's a true chick flick, if
there ever was one. For opening weekend, for the early
matinee, there was a grand total of 1 guy in the theater. And
the line for the next matinee appeared to be all women. If
you're a guy and you want to please your gal, then do consider it,
but if ladies, if you're suggesting this film to your man, you
might want to think twice. You might be better off to make
this one a girls'-night-out kindof flick.
Whomever you go to see it
with, be prepared to talk about the life-lessons in it.
You'll be glad that you were able to see more about these four
women and how their story has unfolded. Even if it's
disappointing at some level, it's what has happened to them that is
meaningful. There isn't a truly happily ever after for
everyone, but life does go on nonetheless, and it's important to
see what Life (with a capital L) brings these characters, which
continue to replay earlier times not only in syndication but in
many fan's hearts.